Pumpernickel Sandwich Bread Recipe

Ingredients
Equipment
Directions
FAQs
Find answers to your most pressing questions about this delicious recipe right here.
Traditional pumpernickel sandwich bread requires rye flour, bread flour, whole wheat flour, cocoa powder, instant coffee, molasses, caraway seeds, yeast, salt, vegetable oil, and water. These ingredients create the signature dark colour and complex, earthy flavour profile.
Learn how to cook Pumpernickel Sandwich Bread by combining flours with cocoa powder, coffee, and molasses for authentic dark colour. After two rises, bake with steam at 190°C, then reduce to 175°C until the internal temperature reaches 95-98°C. The secret to perfect pumpernickel is allowing it to cool completely before slicing and resting overnight for optimal flavour development.
The distinctive dark chocolate-brown colour comes from a combination of cocoa powder, instant coffee, and molasses. Traditional German pumpernickel gets its darkness from long, slow baking, but home recipes use these ingredients to achieve similar results without requiring the extended baking time.
While you can replace some bread flour with all-purpose flour, the rye flour is essential for authentic taste and cannot be substituted. The ratio of rye to wheat flour affects texture—more rye creates denser bread. For best results, maintain at least 50% rye flour in your pumpernickel recipe.
Caraway seeds provide the distinctive aromatic, slightly anise-like flavour that's characteristic of traditional pumpernickel. They add complexity with their warm, slightly sharp taste that complements the earthy rye flour. While optional, omitting them would result in a less authentic flavour profile.
Sandwich Bread
Try following recommended recipes