Key Lime Pastries Recipe

Ingredients
Equipment
Directions
FAQs
Find answers to your most pressing questions about this delicious recipe right here.
Key Lime Pastries require plain flour, icing sugar, cold butter, eggs, condensed milk, fresh key lime juice and zest for the filling, plus caster sugar and cream of tartar for the meringue topping. The combination creates perfect balance between buttery pastry and tangy citrus.
Learn how to cook Key Lime Pastries by making three components: a flaky butter pastry (blind baked at 180°C), a tangy lime filling (mixed with condensed milk and baked until just set), and a glossy meringue topping that you can lightly torch for a professional finish. The process involves chilling the pastry, precise baking times, and careful meringue whipping for optimal results.
Yes, you can substitute regular limes, though they're less aromatic than key limes. You'll need 4-5 regular limes to yield the same amount of juice (120ml). For authentic flavour, add a bit more zest, or mix with a small amount of lemon juice to better mimic the distinctive tartness of key limes.
The secret lies in proper blind baking—prick the bases with a fork, use baking beans, and ensure the cases are fully baked until golden before adding filling. Also crucial is allowing the filled pastries to cool completely before adding meringue, as any residual heat or moisture can soften your perfectly crisp pastry.
You can prepare the pastry cases up to 3 days ahead (stored in an airtight container) and the lime filling 1 day ahead (refrigerated). For best results, assemble with the meringue no more than 24 hours before serving. The pastries are at their prime when freshly assembled, with crisp pastry contrasting beautifully with the soft filling.
Puff Pastry
Try following recommended recipes